Newlywed actors Reeve Carney and Eva Noblezada, who star as Jay and Daisy in Broadway’s “The Great Gatsby,” have a marriage right out of a romance novel. But when the couple met in 2017 at a reading for the musical “Hadestown,” Noblezada thought their pairing would not even be believable to audiences. “He’s so handsome. And I just wasn’t confident the way that I am now. So going back and seeing him, I remember being like, ‘You guys want us to play lovers, that’s hilarious,'” she told The Post. Eva Noblezada and Reeve Carney are currently starring on Broadway together in “The Great Gatsby.” Tamara Beckwith/NY Post And Carney, 43, didn’t see a future where they’d even be friends. “Funnily enough, I didn’t think Eva liked me. And she didn’t think that I liked her,” he recalled. “I was nervous,” added Noblezada, 30.…