Logo text [This story contains spoilers from So I Married an Axe Murderer .] In 1993’s So I Married an Axe Murderer , Mike Myers thought he married an axe murderer (and then he didn’t, and then he did again, and then he found out, factually, that he did not). As it turns out, the killer was Amanda Plummer’s character, not Nancy Travis’, with the axe, in whatever room(s) in which she murdered Travis’ (onscreen) ex-husbands. Myers and Travis’ Charlie and Harriet live happily ever after, probably, with the exception that she has to spend the rest of her days listening to his beat poetry. In the 2026 Netflix docuseries Should I Marry a Murderer? , Dr. Caroline Muirhead factually knows her Scottish fiancé Alexander McKellar killed an innocent man and buried him on a farm, but she moves back in with him anyway. The title is provocative and very easy to answer (“No!”), but it is posed as a legitimate question that Muirhead faces at least twice in the three-part documentary now streaming.…