Season 1: Cormac Murphy and Season 5: Johnnie Garcia Instagram Starting things off with a little-known Love Island USA romance between season 1’s Cormac and season 5’s Johnnie, which began back in early 2024. Season 4: Kat Gibson and Bryce Fins Instagram Fun fact: These two actually got together post-Villa, hard-launching their relationship on Instagram in February 2025 (and as far as I know, they’re still together today!). Advertisement - Continue Reading Below Season 5: Marco Donatelli and Hannah Wright Amanda Edwards // Getty Images After winning the $100,000 prize in 2023, Hannah Wright and Marco Donatelli went on to become the first Love Island USA couple to get engaged in May 2025. Love that for them!! Season 5: Carsten “Bergie” Bergersen and Taylor Smith Peacock // Getty Images Not everyone was rooting for Taylor and Bergie, but the two are defying all odds and are still together.…