Menu

📰
0

Am I crazy to think that the UAI authors are confusing the discussion deadline with the rebuttal deadline ? [D]

Reddit r/MachineLearning·u/DazzlingPin3965·about 1 month ago
#E1PMjxQK
Reading 0:00
15s threshold

Am I crazy to think that the UAI authors are confusing the discussion deadline with the rebuttal deadline ? [D] Hello everyone. UAI review results were released last Thursday, and the discussion period was clearly stated as April 23 to May 2nd. However, none of the papers I reviewed have yet published their rebuttals. I believe this confusion arises because people are mistakenly equating the discussion deadline with the rebuttal deadline. For example, ICML has a rebuttal deadline followed by a discussion period, but this isn’t the case here. If authors wait until May 2nd to submit their rebuttals, they won’t have the opportunity to address any additional questions or engage in further discussion with the reviewers nor will the reviewers be able to raise any follow up question. As an author, I’ve already submitted my rebuttal, but only one reviewer has responded. Additionally, I’ve noticed that when a reviewer responds to your rebuttal, the other reviewers do not see it.…

Continue reading — create a free account

Join HashtagPLUS to read full articles, follow hashtags, vote, and join the conversation.

Read More