The singer who finished in sixth place in season five performed a duet with current contestant Hannah Harper on Martina McBride's song "A Broken Wing." Hannah Harper and Kellie Pickler perform Martina McBride's "A Broken Wing" on May 4, 2026 during season 24 of "American Idol." ABC/American Idol/YouTube Trending on Billboard Kellie Pickler joined some of her fellow American Idol season five alumni for a 20th anniversary reunion on Monday night (May 4) in one of the country singer’s first live performances since the death of her husband Kyle Jacobs, in 2023 . The emotional return by the sixth-place finisher included a powerful, moving duet on Martina McBride’s 1997 ballad “A Broken Wing” with one of this year’s semifinalists, Hannah Harper.…